Skip to main content

Veganism or vegetarianism - are they really sustainable?

Hello everyone

Does veganism come with health issues? Is it sustainable? And does vegetarianism change anything? - We're going to be comparing three different diet types: veganism, vegetarianism, and a mixed diet, in multiple categories. This post is structured into the following sections:
  1. human rights
  2. health
  3. area needed
  4. animal rights
  5. greenhouse gas emissions
  6. Which diet is the best?
  7. Image and text sources
Warning: There are no graphic images in this post. However, in the 'human rights' and 'animal rights' sections, there are descriptions of physical and mental abuse towards both humans and animals. Skip those sections, if you know you can't deal with that.

Human rights

This may seem like an unrelated topic at first, but in many industries, the rights of people in poorer countries are abused because it's cheaper for the company to have workers in a country with a low min. wage than to have workers in a country with a high min. wage. However, this means that the workers are paid very little and this will often come hand in hand with child labour. So this is a very important subject to discuss.
So the industry that we need to look at first is the meat industry.

Meat industry

There have been allegations of human rights abuse in the U.S. meat industry in a report Blood, Sweat, and Fear: Workers' Rights in U.S. Meat and Poultry Plants from Human's rights watch. Other reports also describe terrible work environments, being convinced to not report injuries, no proper training, and additional injuries due to performing the same motions over and over again. As the human rights watch said in this article:
Workers often do not receive compensation for workplace injuries because companies fail to report injuries, delay and deny claims, and take reprisals against workers who file them.
The meat packaging industry also seems to be a big problem, with reports of undocumented workers from other countries being exploited. There are no unions to protect the workers.

Fish industry

There have been reports of fishing industries in Thailand getting immigrant workers from poorer countries to work for them instead of raising the pay for their already existing workers. This industry has become known for human trafficking, child labour, and forced labour. Again this comes with the problem of violence and injuries not being reported. Workers can even be deprived of basic human needs like showers and meals. Over 94% of the crew has no contract according to this Greenpeace graphic, with workers being beaten if they did not do as told.

Crop industry

There are multiple allegations of human rights abuse in the crop industry. Here are a couple:
  1. An anonymous farm worker reported trafficking set up over borders and was promised a different job to the one they received, with bad living and working conditions.
  2. We've already talked about this one in our palm oil post. Workers in Indonesia undergo false promises of high wages, getting caught in dept, trafficking, being beaten, having their passports taken, no maternity leave, unsafe equipment, no sick days & child labour.
  3. Reports of bad working conditions and exploitation in the wheat industry.

Summary

In this section, there is no real winner. The dairy industry seems to be the only one where there are very few reports however we may never truly know what goes on behind closed doors. It is important to mention that although there are more allegations in the crop industry, the meat and dairy industry both, at least partially, rely on the crop industry to feed their animals. In conclusion, in the area of human rights, almost every industry does have some major problems that need addressing.

Health

This is a big topic. When it comes to vegetarianism and veganism, many people worry about the impact that these diets could have on your health.

Red meat

Red meat is an important source of multiple different vitamins and minerals and is a source of protein. However multiple studies have shown that eating red meat seems to increase the risk of heart disease, chest cancer, and type 2 diabetes. Although this seems to be more like when it comes to processed meats.

White meat

Studies have very different opinions on this matter. Some claim that white meat is just as bad or even worse than red meat, while others say that white meat is far better than red meat. When it comes to claims that it is bad for your health, normally the same things are said about red meat and that eating white meat can lead to early death.

Dairy

The standard sentence of 'more milk gives you stronger bones' is now very controversial and scientists are having a hard time working out whether dairy is good for you or not. Diary contains calcium and protein, which are both good for you. However, there are other sources for this and alarming studies have shown that dairy intake might contribute to breast and prostate cancer. At the same time, some studies show the exact opposite, so it is quite hard to work out what's true and what isn't.

Summary

Again it is quite hard to tell which is the best. However, the general understanding is that too much meat/dairy is bad for you and that most people eat too much. There are some things that you can only get from meat, for instance, B12. However, there are some vegan sources for these and if you don't have any other options then there are supplements for pretty much everything. It is also worth mentioning that if it weren't for the animal industry, we wouldn't be dealing with COVID-19 and many other viruses.

Area needed

This is an important topic. With the world population growing at alarming rates, we need food sources that take up as little space as possible.

70% of the world's agricultural land is used for meat, dairy, and other animal products. This is because cattle require a lot of land for grazing and land is also required to grow animal feed. However, when looking at how much protein we get from animal products, although different sources vary massively, most seem to agree that we only get about one-third of our protein from animal products. So basically we use 70% of our agricultural land but only get about 33% of our protein from it. The meat industry is also responsible for the majority of the deforestation in the amazon rainforest. 

Animal rights

This is where veganism and vegetarianism become a lot more appealing than an omnivore diet.

Beef, Pork & Chicken

There are multiple reports of the mistreatment of animals in the meat industry including: 
  1. branding
  2. being left to die of starvation
  3. being left to freeze to death
  4. being beaten
  5. implanted with hormones
  6. stunned
  7. being strung upside down while still conscious
  8. being boiled alive
  9. not enough space to lie down or move
  10. testicles being ripped out while conscious without painkillers
  11. tails cut off while conscious
  12. no vets for the sick or injured
  13. females being constantly forced to give birth and then being separated from their young
  14. piglets being thrown across the room
  15. spread of diseases

Dairy

Dairy cows are treated appallingly and live in terrible conditions. There are 2.5 million dairy cows in the UK alone and far too many of them have spent their entire lives in a barn or factory. The milk adverts with happy cows walking across a massive open pasture with enough grass and enough shade are just not true. Some cows have never even seen daylight.
To produce milk, a cow must be pregnant. So the cows are impregnated. After months of pregnancy (during which she will be kept in an enclosure so small that it's hard to lie down), she gives birth to her calf. The calf will be separated from her within the first few hours. If it is a female, it may survive, but only to be raised for the same fate as her mother. If it's a male, it will most likely be shot in the head and/or left to die.

The mother will be attached to a machine that will take her milk. Once she stops producing milk, the whole cycle starts again. Of course, at some point she will be too old, then she will be killed and used for cheap meat or leather.

Summary

It is quite clear, that when it comes to animal abuse veganism and vegetarianism are the way forward.

Greenhouse gas emissions

In our last section, we are going to be comparing the greenhouse gas emissions in the agricultural industry. More than a third of all emissions come from food production and according to a guardian article, 57% of all greenhouse gases in the food sector come from the meat industry, whereas only 29% of the food sector comes from plant-based food production. Beef is the biggest producer followed by cow milk. It is also worth mentioning that many of the emissions due to beef and cow milk are methane, which is much worse than CO2.

So which diet is the best?

More factors play into this and in some cultures, it is much harder to be vegetarian or vegan, unfortunately, it is often more expensive. However, from what we've looked at today, we need to cut down on meat and dairy, especially looking at the animal abuse section.

Your Green World Blog Team💚


Images:

Title image: This image is owned by a blog editor.
Workers on fishing boat: This image, owned by ILO Asia-Pacific (on flickr.com), is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 2.0.
Palm oil worker: This image, owned by ILO Asia-Pacific (on flickr.com), is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 2.0.
Amazon rainforest: This image, owned by Stephen Bové (on flickr.com), is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 2.0.
Cows in barn: This image, owned by J. Nisly (on flickr.com), is licensed under CC BY-NC.SA 2.0.

Text sources:

Human rights - meat industry


Human rights - fish industry


Human rights - crop industry

Health - red meat


Health - white meat


Health - diary


Area needed


Animal rights - beef, pork & chicken


Animal rights - dairy


Greenhouse gas emissions

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

16.08.2020 Animal of the week: Elephant

Hello. On the 12th of August it was International Elephant Day, so we decided that this week's post should be about elephants. Elephants are the largest living land mammals. There are three types of elephant; the African bush elephant; the African forest elephant and the Asian elephant. African elephants have larger ears, whereas Asian elephants have smaller ears. Elephants use their trunks to breath, bring food and drink to their mouths and to grasp objects. Elephants' legs are like pillars. They carry the Elephant's massive weight. African bush elephants weigh 6000kg, Asian elephants weigh 4000kg and African forest elephants weigh 2700kg. Basically, they are very heavy.Elephants eat grasses, small plants, bushes, fruit, twigs, tree bark, and roots. Elephants can live up to 70 years old in the wild. They communicate by sight, touch and smell. Sadly, these wonderful mammals are in danger. African elephants are listed as vulne...

Ozone layer

Hi everyone, What even is ozone? And the ozone layer? Where does the hole in the ozone layer come from and what does it mean? Is it dangerous? What can be done? Often the ozone-talk can be complicated and confusing, keeping an overview is hard and understanding all the problems always difficult. Let us break it down a bit for you: What is the ozone layer? We'll start with the basics: The ozone layer is part of the stratosphere, which is the second layer of the Earth's atmosphere, between 10 and 50 km above the Earth's surface and made up of protective gases. One of these protective gases is ozone. There is not much ozone in the atmosphere, only 0.3 molecule of ozone per 1 million molecules of air. This is because ozone is chemically unstable and only forms when ultra violet radiation (UV light) hits oxygen and breaks the bonds between the atoms. It fact it is so unstable that even when it has formed, it breaks down again relatively quickly. This leads to ozone turning back ...

10 animals on the edge of extinction you didn't know about no. 9 - South Island takahē

Hello Today we’re talking about the South Island takahē, porphyrio hochstetteri . They are flightless birds, endemic to New Zealand. Takahē are brightly coloured and weigh 2.3-3.8 kg. They have red legs and a large red beak. Their feathers are coloured blue and green. They have wings, but these are only used during courtship or rivalry displays. They are territorial, with one family’s territory reaching anywhere from 4 ha to 100 ha (0,04-1km^2). Pairs will live in the same territory each year. They breed once a year and will raise 1-3 chicks (normally 2) each year.  Both parents raise the chicks together.  In the wild, takahē live in native grasslands and have a lifespan of 16-18 years. If snow covers the ground then they will move into nearby forests. They eat tussock grasses, sedges and sometimes rushes. But they are opportunists, so they will occasionally go for insects or even ducklings and...

The Responsible Traveller by Karen Edwards || a practical guide to reducing your environmental and social impact // BOOK REVIEW

HI Everyone! Our January monthly post was a zero-waste challenge, but as we explained in our  2023 wrap up , this year we will be alternating a monthly challenge with a book review, of course related to the environment. This week, I'm going to share a recommendation for a fantastic book, all about how you can travel more sustainably and responsibly. I absolutely love travelling, but I'm also very aware of the impact it has on the world, and I am very keen to learn more about how I can further reduce my impact. That's why I bought this book around a year ago, and I've really enjoyed reading it and learning from it.  This is a practical, small-format guide, sharing both basic information about the climate crisis and the impact of various travel activities, and how you can do your bit. It shares specific journeys that are more environmentally friendly options, for example long distance train journeys such as The Alaskan Railroad with its stunning alpine forests and wide ar...

How much do you know about marine animals? | quiz

Hi Everyone! Welcome to another monthly quiz! Today we are so excited to share some quiz questions on marine animals. Let us know how you did in the comments! Questions 1) Which of these came first: sharks, dinosaurs or jellyfish? 2) How many electric bulbs could an electric eel light up? 3) True of False: dolphins sleep with only half their brain. 4) True or False: an octopus has purple blood. 5) What is the loudest sound made by a marine animal (and indeed any animal on the planet!)? 6) True or False: oysters are all female. 7) In which animal species do the males and not the females give birth and care for their young? 8) True or False: a shrimp's heart is in its head. 9) True or False: sea sponges have no head, brain, mouth, eyes, feelers, bones, heart, or lungs. 10) How many continents do turtles live in? Answers: 1) Jellyfish! They've been around for more than 650 million years. 2) 10 3) True! They also...

Pollination

Hello everyone, Today we're talking about pollination and its importance in the world's ecosystems.  First a bit of basic plant biology. To reproduce most plants do have a differentiation into male and female, but not in the same way that we see in mammals. Both male and female reproductive organs can be found on the same plant, although not in the same place. Male gametes are produced in the stamens and are then found in pollen. On the other hand, female reproductive organs are called pistils and egg cells are found in the ovule (normally in the flower heads). Pollination describes the process of transporting the pollen to the egg cells, making it an essential part of the reproduction of plants. Nearly all seed plants worldwide require pollination to reproduce. Cone bearing trees also need pollination.  Pollination is almost always assisted by other organisms such as insects, birds and mammals to transport the pollen. In some species wind ...

Biodiversity

Hello, Today we're talking about biodiversity and why it's so important. As you probably know biodiversity describes the variety of living species, often referring to one specific place or ecosystem. For example, the Amazon rainforest is a very biodiverse ecosystem. The opposite of biodiverse is a monoculture. A monoculture often refers to farmland, where only one crop is produced. Palm oil plantations are normally monocultures, with rows and rows of palm trees and nothing else. I'm going to start by giving you an idea of the current situation. This year, the State of Nature 2023 report was published. This report looks at recent changes in biodiversity in the UK. To be frank, it's bad news. One in six (17%) of all UK species and almost half (43%) of bird species are at risk of extinction. 31% of amphibians and reptiles and 28% of fungi are also at risk. There has been a 54% decline in flowering plant species and a 34% decline in ...

Carbon credits

Hi everyone, Welcome back to Green World! Today we're talking about an industry that has expanded massively in the past few years. Carbon credits are one of the measures that companies are taking to reduce CO2 emissions . But how does it actually work? The companies that sell carbon credits fund projects to protect an area of forest or rainforest from deforestation . They then calculate how much carbon dioxide emissions they have saves by protecting this area. This means they can now sell 'negative carbon emissions' to companies. In this way, the companies are funding the protection of said area and are causing negative emissions while doing so meaning that the company can still emit greenhouse gases but can claim to be net zero. One carbon credit is basically the permission to emit one ton of CO2. This is good for the company as well as they are able to advertise as sustainable at a relatively low cost to actually reducing the...

Ecotourism: what it is, the advantages and the disadvantages

Hi Everyone! Today we wanted to talk about the idea of ecotourism, including the advantages and disadvantages of this concept. If you are looking to reduce your environmental and social impact when travelling, then this is the post for you! Ecotourism is a form of tourism which limits the damage to the environment and local community. It can involve helping in community projects such as planting trees, as well as taking part in local customs and festivals. It helps to keep the local culture alive, while preserving the natural environment.  The advantages are abundant. By helping in a project conserving the environment, tourists gain a new understanding and appreciation for the natural world and may be inspired to make changes in their "real" life to live more sustainably. It provides a valuable insight to a country and community, perhaps also inspiring more respect for different people and the lives they lead. The projects also provide sustainable income sources for locals, h...

Zero-waste Challenge

Hi everyone,  Welcome back to Green World for our first post of 2024! As explained in our wrap up post, this year the monthly series will switch between challenges and book reviews. We're starting with a challenge and this month we're challenging you to cut down on your waste! 1. No single use plastic bags challenge Plastic bags are a disaster for the environment and they're not always even usable for us. Some of the really thin plastic bags will just rip as soon as you put something in them which is a nightmare if you're out shopping and need to transport your groceries home. When these plastic bags are then thrown away, they cause significant damage to our planet. Plastic bags often clog waterways and sewers which is a massive problem. Waterways, such as streams, and their ecosystems depend on moving water and if they get too blocked, the migration of different species is hindered. If a dam starts to form with all of the sticks, rocks and more plastic that is being tr...