Skip to main content

Veganism or vegetarianism - are they really sustainable?

Hello everyone

Does veganism come with health issues? Is it sustainable? And does vegetarianism change anything? - We're going to be comparing three different diet types: veganism, vegetarianism, and a mixed diet, in multiple categories. This post is structured into the following sections:
  1. human rights
  2. health
  3. area needed
  4. animal rights
  5. greenhouse gas emissions
  6. Which diet is the best?
  7. Image and text sources
Warning: There are no graphic images in this post. However, in the 'human rights' and 'animal rights' sections, there are descriptions of physical and mental abuse towards both humans and animals. Skip those sections, if you know you can't deal with that.

Human rights

This may seem like an unrelated topic at first, but in many industries, the rights of people in poorer countries are abused because it's cheaper for the company to have workers in a country with a low min. wage than to have workers in a country with a high min. wage. However, this means that the workers are paid very little and this will often come hand in hand with child labour. So this is a very important subject to discuss.
So the industry that we need to look at first is the meat industry.

Meat industry

There have been allegations of human rights abuse in the U.S. meat industry in a report Blood, Sweat, and Fear: Workers' Rights in U.S. Meat and Poultry Plants from Human's rights watch. Other reports also describe terrible work environments, being convinced to not report injuries, no proper training, and additional injuries due to performing the same motions over and over again. As the human rights watch said in this article:
Workers often do not receive compensation for workplace injuries because companies fail to report injuries, delay and deny claims, and take reprisals against workers who file them.
The meat packaging industry also seems to be a big problem, with reports of undocumented workers from other countries being exploited. There are no unions to protect the workers.

Fish industry

There have been reports of fishing industries in Thailand getting immigrant workers from poorer countries to work for them instead of raising the pay for their already existing workers. This industry has become known for human trafficking, child labour, and forced labour. Again this comes with the problem of violence and injuries not being reported. Workers can even be deprived of basic human needs like showers and meals. Over 94% of the crew has no contract according to this Greenpeace graphic, with workers being beaten if they did not do as told.

Crop industry

There are multiple allegations of human rights abuse in the crop industry. Here are a couple:
  1. An anonymous farm worker reported trafficking set up over borders and was promised a different job to the one they received, with bad living and working conditions.
  2. We've already talked about this one in our palm oil post. Workers in Indonesia undergo false promises of high wages, getting caught in dept, trafficking, being beaten, having their passports taken, no maternity leave, unsafe equipment, no sick days & child labour.
  3. Reports of bad working conditions and exploitation in the wheat industry.

Summary

In this section, there is no real winner. The dairy industry seems to be the only one where there are very few reports however we may never truly know what goes on behind closed doors. It is important to mention that although there are more allegations in the crop industry, the meat and dairy industry both, at least partially, rely on the crop industry to feed their animals. In conclusion, in the area of human rights, almost every industry does have some major problems that need addressing.

Health

This is a big topic. When it comes to vegetarianism and veganism, many people worry about the impact that these diets could have on your health.

Red meat

Red meat is an important source of multiple different vitamins and minerals and is a source of protein. However multiple studies have shown that eating red meat seems to increase the risk of heart disease, chest cancer, and type 2 diabetes. Although this seems to be more like when it comes to processed meats.

White meat

Studies have very different opinions on this matter. Some claim that white meat is just as bad or even worse than red meat, while others say that white meat is far better than red meat. When it comes to claims that it is bad for your health, normally the same things are said about red meat and that eating white meat can lead to early death.

Dairy

The standard sentence of 'more milk gives you stronger bones' is now very controversial and scientists are having a hard time working out whether dairy is good for you or not. Diary contains calcium and protein, which are both good for you. However, there are other sources for this and alarming studies have shown that dairy intake might contribute to breast and prostate cancer. At the same time, some studies show the exact opposite, so it is quite hard to work out what's true and what isn't.

Summary

Again it is quite hard to tell which is the best. However, the general understanding is that too much meat/dairy is bad for you and that most people eat too much. There are some things that you can only get from meat, for instance, B12. However, there are some vegan sources for these and if you don't have any other options then there are supplements for pretty much everything. It is also worth mentioning that if it weren't for the animal industry, we wouldn't be dealing with COVID-19 and many other viruses.

Area needed

This is an important topic. With the world population growing at alarming rates, we need food sources that take up as little space as possible.

70% of the world's agricultural land is used for meat, dairy, and other animal products. This is because cattle require a lot of land for grazing and land is also required to grow animal feed. However, when looking at how much protein we get from animal products, although different sources vary massively, most seem to agree that we only get about one-third of our protein from animal products. So basically we use 70% of our agricultural land but only get about 33% of our protein from it. The meat industry is also responsible for the majority of the deforestation in the amazon rainforest. 

Animal rights

This is where veganism and vegetarianism become a lot more appealing than an omnivore diet.

Beef, Pork & Chicken

There are multiple reports of the mistreatment of animals in the meat industry including: 
  1. branding
  2. being left to die of starvation
  3. being left to freeze to death
  4. being beaten
  5. implanted with hormones
  6. stunned
  7. being strung upside down while still conscious
  8. being boiled alive
  9. not enough space to lie down or move
  10. testicles being ripped out while conscious without painkillers
  11. tails cut off while conscious
  12. no vets for the sick or injured
  13. females being constantly forced to give birth and then being separated from their young
  14. piglets being thrown across the room
  15. spread of diseases

Dairy

Dairy cows are treated appallingly and live in terrible conditions. There are 2.5 million dairy cows in the UK alone and far too many of them have spent their entire lives in a barn or factory. The milk adverts with happy cows walking across a massive open pasture with enough grass and enough shade are just not true. Some cows have never even seen daylight.
To produce milk, a cow must be pregnant. So the cows are impregnated. After months of pregnancy (during which she will be kept in an enclosure so small that it's hard to lie down), she gives birth to her calf. The calf will be separated from her within the first few hours. If it is a female, it may survive, but only to be raised for the same fate as her mother. If it's a male, it will most likely be shot in the head and/or left to die.

The mother will be attached to a machine that will take her milk. Once she stops producing milk, the whole cycle starts again. Of course, at some point she will be too old, then she will be killed and used for cheap meat or leather.

Summary

It is quite clear, that when it comes to animal abuse veganism and vegetarianism are the way forward.

Greenhouse gas emissions

In our last section, we are going to be comparing the greenhouse gas emissions in the agricultural industry. More than a third of all emissions come from food production and according to a guardian article, 57% of all greenhouse gases in the food sector come from the meat industry, whereas only 29% of the food sector comes from plant-based food production. Beef is the biggest producer followed by cow milk. It is also worth mentioning that many of the emissions due to beef and cow milk are methane, which is much worse than CO2.

So which diet is the best?

More factors play into this and in some cultures, it is much harder to be vegetarian or vegan, unfortunately, it is often more expensive. However, from what we've looked at today, we need to cut down on meat and dairy, especially looking at the animal abuse section.

Your Green World Blog Team💚


Images:

Title image: This image is owned by a blog editor.
Workers on fishing boat: This image, owned by ILO Asia-Pacific (on flickr.com), is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 2.0.
Palm oil worker: This image, owned by ILO Asia-Pacific (on flickr.com), is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 2.0.
Amazon rainforest: This image, owned by Stephen Bové (on flickr.com), is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 2.0.
Cows in barn: This image, owned by J. Nisly (on flickr.com), is licensed under CC BY-NC.SA 2.0.

Text sources:

Human rights - meat industry


Human rights - fish industry


Human rights - crop industry

Health - red meat


Health - white meat


Health - diary


Area needed


Animal rights - beef, pork & chicken


Animal rights - dairy


Greenhouse gas emissions

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

16.08.2020 Animal of the week: Elephant

Hello. On the 12th of August it was International Elephant Day, so we decided that this week's post should be about elephants. Elephants are the largest living land mammals. There are three types of elephant; the African bush elephant; the African forest elephant and the Asian elephant. African elephants have larger ears, whereas Asian elephants have smaller ears. Elephants use their trunks to breath, bring food and drink to their mouths and to grasp objects. Elephants' legs are like pillars. They carry the Elephant's massive weight. African bush elephants weigh 6000kg, Asian elephants weigh 4000kg and African forest elephants weigh 2700kg. Basically, they are very heavy.Elephants eat grasses, small plants, bushes, fruit, twigs, tree bark, and roots. Elephants can live up to 70 years old in the wild. They communicate by sight, touch and smell. Sadly, these wonderful mammals are in danger. African elephants are listed as vulne...

Climate change: what is it and what's the problem

Hello, I've noticed that we are always mentioning climate change. Not only us blog editors but also politicians, activists and so on. The words climate change are bounced around in the media and probably in your households, but do you actually know what it is or how it works? I know that for a long time, I didn't know what it really meant. I hope that this post changes that. What is climate change and how does it work? The words climate change describe a slow shift in the earth's temperature and changes in the weather patterns. Having a single warm winter does not instantly mean climate change. Climate change happens over a long period of time. If you look at a temperature graph over the years, it doesn't go up in one day and then stay the same for another hundred years. It curves up slowly but steadily. This is a average temperature graph from 1880 to just after 2000. You can see how the temperature gradually gets warmer....

30.08.2020 Animal of the week: Whale Shark

Hi! It is International Whale Shark Day today, so we thought, we would do this week's animal of the week about whale sharks. Are whale sharks, sharks or whales? Whale sharks are not whales and they aren't a mix of whale and shark. They are sharks. So, why are they called whale sharks if they aren't whales? Well, they are very big. Whale sharks normally grow to a length of 5.5-10 metres. However, the largest whale shark to be accurately measured was 18.8 metres long! That is about as long as a lorry or as high as a short oak tree. Basically, whale sharks are massive. Habitat and Diet Whale sharks prefer warmer waters. They live in all tropical seas. Every spring, they are known to migrate to the continental shelf of the central west coast of Australia. The whale shark is one of the three known filter-feeding shark species in the world. Like whales, they eat plankton.  Images: Image 1:  This image is o...

Heatwaves - what's so bad about them?

Hi everyone, Today we’re talking about heatwaves and what effects they have on us and the environment. Heatwaves are becoming ever more common, with 2023 breaking multiple world records. In China, 52.2°C were recorded at one point and the coastal waters near Florida, USA, were as warm as a hot tub. This is because of the combination of climate change and El Niño , both of which make the effects of the other worse. But we can’t push the blame onto El Niño. When analysed it became clear that without human made climate change the USA heat records would have been almost impossible. So what exactly are the effects of such high temperatures. A study in Europe found that the 2022 heatwave possibly caused over 70 000 heat related deaths. Although it is sometimes hard to tell whether or not someone died from the heat or from something else, after analysing the data the team found that their original estimate of 62 000 people (which is still a lot) was probably ...

Animals 46-50 in our '50 incredible animals' series

Hi everyone! Welcome to the final part in our '50 Incredible Animal series' where you can find out about animals 46-50. We started this series almost a year ago to celebrate our 50th post and it feels crazy to think that we are now nearing our 100th. To read all of the previous posts from this series, click here . Hope you enjoy it! 46. Spiny bush viper Spiny bush vipers, Atheris hispida, are a species of venomous snake native to Central and East Africa in tropical forests and shrubland. They are mostly solitary creatures but can climb trees, which is where they find the majority of their prey. Spiny bush vipers are carnivorous and feed on mammals, frogs and lizards, as well as birds. Independent from birth, Spiny bush vipers can have up to 12 'snakelets' at a time and are 15cm in length. Currently, there are no known threats to Spiny bush vipers, and they are categorized as Not Evaluated on the IUCN Red List. 47. Leafy sea dragon ...

An exciting initiative from Co-op and Sainsbury's...

Hi Everyone! Today I want to tell you about something I think is very exciting. If you want to recycle more plastic then this could be your chance! Co-op and Sainsbury's have both launched a new soft plastics recycling scheme where you bring your 'soft plastics' (things like crisp packets, chocolate wrappers and fruit and veg bags) into a designated area. For 'hard plastics' such as yoghurt pots, juice cartons and fruit and veg punnets, you can use either your local kerbside collection but not every area collects plastics in this way, including mine so we collect ours and bring it to the tip ourselves. To check if it's a soft plastic you can use the scrunch test- scrunch up the object and if it pings back then it is probably plastic. Then you need to clean it and bring it into one of the stores. Co-op even accepts plastics from other retailers! Co-op uses the plastic to make bin bags for use in the store which I think is a g...

How well do you know the Arctic and the Antarctic? - Quiz

Welcome back to Green World, As announced last week, we're starting our new monthly series: quizzes! This post contains the questions, you have to write down the answers and compare them with the solutions right at the bottom of this post.  Questions: True or False? The Arctic is not actually a land mass, it's a frozen ocean. How many people live in the Arctic circle? a) 500 000 b) 4 million c) 10 million True or False? Narwals don't actually have unicorn-like horns. That's just a legend. What percentage of the world's freshwater is frozen within the Arctic's ice? a) 10% b) 15% c) 20% True or False? The Arctic covers parts of 15 different countries. Scientists exploring Antarctica have measured winds of up to... a) 100 km/h b) 150km/h c) 200km/h True or False? The driest (natural) place on Earth is in Antarctica...

06.09.2020 Animal Of the Week: Seven-spotted Ladybird

Hello Everyone, Welcome to this week's animal of the week post. This time about the ladybird, and personally I can't wait to find out more about these creatures. Enjoy! Which ladybird we are investigating today? Today, I am telling you about the seven-spotted ladybird (Coccinella septempunctata), which is the most common ladybird in Europe. Other species include the Two Spot Ladybird and other uncommon ladybirds such as the 16 Spot and other peculiar types. Habitat The seven-spotted ladybird lives in a variety of habitats such as meadows, gardens and hedgerows. They can also be found on farmland, especially with crops such as alfalfa, clover and wheat and corn before it grows too tall. Diet The seven-spotted ladybird feeds on a range of aphid species. This is why they are often referred to as a gardener's best friend as they eat these creatures who can damage plants. They can also eat white flies and anything else that is soft-bo...

New IPCC Report 2022

Hi everyone, You've probably heard about the new IPCC report that was released earlier this year. In this post, we wanted to talk about what it is and how it could affect us. We haven't read the whole 3000+ page document, surprisingly, but people on the internet have so we have used information from reliable sources, including the IPCC website. What is the IPCC? IPCC stands for Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. It is governments and scientists from all over the world work together to produce reports about the effects of climate change. When did that new report come out? 4th April 2022 What does the new report say and what does it mean for us? The report states that average annual global greenhouse gas emissions were at their highest levels in human history between 2010 to 2019, but the rate of growth of emissions has since slowed. Emissions must peak by 2025 and then must fall drastically (43% by 2030) if we are to limit the d...

Maria Sibylla Merian

Hello, Today we wanted to tell you all about Maria Sibylla Merian. Maria was born in Germany on 2nd April, 1647. Like many young girls at that time, she loved to paint. Every day she would gather flowers from her garden and paint them. Sometimes, the flowers would have caterpillars on them and she would paint them changing, day by day, into butterflies. At that time, not much was known about insects, and people thought that butterflies magically sprouted from the mud. Maria knew from what she had seen while she was painting, that this was not true, but no-one believed her. As time went by, Maria became a great watercolour artist. She wrote about her discoveries, but scientists only took books written in Latin seriously, and Maria wrote hers in German. When Maria and her daughter were living in Amsterdam, Maria found display cases in museums filled with exotic insects collected from South America. Maria thought that if she could study the bu...